Monday, January 31, 2022

Luddite or Modernist?

If you've ever watched an older episode of “NCIS” you'll notice that the main character, “Gibbs” (Mark Harmon), only uses a flip-phone. He's basically a Luddite who doesn't want to upgrade to the fancy new phones because he either wants to cling to the old ways or just doesn’t want to take the time to learn how to adapt to the newer phones.

His comrades put up with this because, well, he's the boss. Plus, they really like him and just think of it as a quirk. 

Some folks might even say it's endearing, but to me, it's a representation of many people today who selectively choose what new technology to embrace. Unless it's for economic or environmental reasons, I find it irritating. 

Do these modern-day Luddites want to return to outdoor plumbing? 

Dirt/mud roads or paved?

 

Horses instead of cars?  (before you say, “oh, I’d like to ride a horse” remember it takes more effort to maintain a horse. You can’t just put it in the garage. Plus, although greenhouse gases are a problem, think about, ahem, piles in the street). 

 

Would you prefer to light your house with candles or do you like to be able to see things more clearly by flipping a switch?

The one that really gets me though is that so many people say they prefer printed books to ebooks. Admittedly, I’m biased because all of my books are electronic.

These people say they prefer the printed copy, yet they will write an email rather than scribble a letter by hand. They read those emails on their phone; they don’t print them out see what Mom has to say. Likewise, they use the “map app” on their phone rather than get out a paper map to see where the dentists’ office is located. They post a picture on Facebook of their trip to the local bar instead of going over to their BFF’s house to tell about their exploits.  

So, these anti-ebook Luddites either need to be consistent or join the rest of us in the 21st Century and read the latest by Stephen King on their iPhone/iPad—while riding in that carriage to their cave.

 

 


3 comments:

  1. I have several Devil's-Advocate-style responses to this.

    If you're consistent, you spend all day long looking at a screen. This is not healthy.

    I know someone who does print out all her emails to read. Actually, I think she has someone do that for her.

    As for me, one problem I have with modern technology is that for many things I prefer ownership over rentals. When I love something, I want to buy it so that I can use it over and over. And to save money, I often buy used. With electronic things, most people rent their music and their movies. You officially can still buy books, until all the technology changes and your books aren't supported anymore. And you can't sell your things at a discount to others when you're done with them.

    And I'd also like to point out that a) like horses, electronic books need maintenance (you have to keep your device charged; in Texas, that means trusting ERCOT). And b) in the olden days, your horse could get you home safely from the bar in a way that driving yourself cannot.

    Disclaimer--I'm one of those people who does not us a smart phone. Oh, the horror! Any respect you once had for me, well, it was nice knowing you! I still call people, play video games, spend way too long on the internet, etc. But I have bigger screens and nicer keyboards.

    I'm sad that one day we won't be able to buy DVDs anymore. We'll just have to hope that Netflix or whoever keeps our favorites in stock and that we always have good enough service to stream (poor Tonga right now; and poor us if Russia is able to cut our cables to Europe like those angry Irish fisherman suspect). Things are not quite as bad as when you had to hope some local theater would play your favorite movie or that a TV station we re-run it or something, but it feels like we're moving in that direction.

    At least I'm pretty cutting edge on vaccines (so long as I can get them without snatching them away from people who need them more). Also, VR mini-golf (Walkabout) has really helped with the socializing during this pandemic. Also, Zoom craft nights.

    In conclusion, most advances aren't better in every single way, even if they are better in most ways or for most people.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Hi Debbie, thanks for reading and commenting. Yes, I'm being a generalist again. I still read paper magazines and newsletters, but have adapted to reading books via my iPad. So I don't really have a problem with people sticking with the old ways. for example, it took me forever to start buying CDs, I kept playing records.Only finally moved to those new fangled things when I couldn't find a recent Midnight Oil release on vinyl. So I'm still one foot in the past and one in the future.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. You're inconsistent? Okay, I have no respect for you anymore. :-)

      I was pretty excited about CDs because they seemed so much more durable than records, not to mention cassettes. (Although the ones I used to get at the library were all scratched up anyway. Were people using them as hockey pucks?)

      The iPad is much nicer for reading than phones, and that's what I play games on.

      One blogger I know likes to put "Deliberately controversial post:" at the beginning of some of her posts. Maybe this is like that. Maybe all your posts are like that. :-)

      Delete